You can pull up almost any media plan, and you'll see the same architecture: a line for search, a line for social, then connected TV, programmatic, digital out of home, and maybe influencers or retail media if the budget stretches that far. Each line has an owner and a number attached, and the plan gets reviewed one line at a time.

But think about how you consumed media yesterday. You had a phone in your hand, a laptop open, something on the TV, probably audio in the car, and you drifted between a creator, a streaming show, a search box and an AI summary without thinking of any of it as a channel.

Andrew Perry, our SVP of Business Development, opened last month's Paid Media Council roundtable on exactly this tension. "Consumers don't experience media that way. They just don't."

He noted that the IAB's 2026 forecast had made a similar case earlier in the year, with fragmentation pushing planners toward channel-agnostic, audience-first models, and then raised questions to the group. Are channel-specific media plans becoming obsolete? Should budgets start with audiences and behaviors rather than with allocations?

Everyone on the agency side recognized the reflex he was describing, where you come out of a discovery call already knowing it's going to be these tactics. What made the hour interesting was how much of it focused on the preconditions for doing it any other way.
 

You have to decide which fairy dust to believe in

Before anyone can plan against audiences, they have to be honest about how they're measuring the plan they already have.

"Attribution is all kind of made up anyway," said a B2B growth consultant. "We distribute points to certain touches, but none of that is real. It's all kind of fairy dust. So you need to go through that exercise of deciding which fairy dust is going to work for you in a revenue sense over time."

He wasn't dismissing measurement. He was arguing that measurement maturity has to come before awareness investment, because otherwise you're putting fifty thousand dollars a month into connected TV, for example, with no way to defend it later.

The instrument this panelist trusts more than any model is a holdout test: pick two geographies close enough to compare, run in one and stay dark in the other, and look at the gap after six weeks or ninety days. "It's a little bit more CFO proof in my experience, because nobody really trusts attribution at the end of the day."

Another performance media veteran added a story from a conference, where someone from a TV ad platform was asked how a client could know whether television was working. The answer was to cancel everything else and let TV run by itself for three months. Even the person selling the channel didn't have a better answer than that.

Andrew described a higher ed project where the team rebuilt the weighted attribution and took credit away from Google. Last-touch reporting had been handing paid search the whole conversion because it produced the session with the form fill in it.

It was plausibly the vehicle that closed, but it almost certainly wasn't what started the journey, and anything outside a 30 day lookback window didn't exist as far as the ad platforms were concerned.
 

Most brands don't have a first-party data plan

If there's one thing that still surprises us in conversations with prospects and clients, it's this. Ask about the first-party data activation plan and, more often than you'd expect, you get a question back instead of an answer.

The mechanics aren't complicated. You take data you already own, meaning CRM records or patient, student or customer lists, and you onboard it through an identity intermediary so it can be activated across social platforms and DSPs.

Andrew's preference is to go through an intermediary rather than uploading straight to each platform, mostly for data augmentation and privacy concerns; giving your data directly to the media outlets unhashed. Your file might have one email for a person. The identity graph may have the work address, two other emails and the rest of the household, and that's what pushes match rates up.

He was realistic about what "up" means in practice. "If we load a list of 10,000 people and get 5,000 matched, we're high fiving over here." Anything much better than that is a number to be suspicious of, as data matching is not 100%.

The B2B consultant walked through how he approaches this for companies spending under a million a year.

You start from a total addressable or serviceable market list. Then you look at the customers you already have who are clearly getting value from you, break the best handful down into firmographic criteria, go back to the list and flag everyone who looks like them, and go after that niche specifically before moving to the next tier.

His reasoning had less to do with targeting precision than with compounding. "The biggest channel in B2B is word of mouth by far. If you tackle that niche specifically, as those customers compound, they'll speak more in that market and that becomes a natural growth flywheel."

He was equally clear about what doesn't count as first-party data. If you're targeting off a third-party aggregator, you're working with maybe a 70% confidence interval, and he said he was being generous.

He knows this partly because one of those databases lists him as an administrator at his father's school district, so his father is the one fielding the ad tech sales calls.
 

The channel was never the differentiator

There's a commercial reason all of this matters for agencies, and it surfaced near the end of the hour.

"Media is the easiest thing to say you're an expert in," Andrew said. Everyone consumes it, everyone buys it, and there are not five different Googles. Every agency on the call is using the same handful of platforms and data providers, which means the tooling is not the pitch.

The consultant's version of what the pitch should be was specific. Recommending digital out of home because of its impact alone goes nowhere. Recommending it along with the ad tech you'll use to track mobile exposure, an honest statement of how far you trust that number, the holdout tests you'll run in named geographies, and the lift you'll be watching for across adjacent channels is a different conversation entirely.

"That's the kind of story that's going to make people believe in your media buying."

He also had a cautionary tale ready, the kind that keeps a client from making the next well documented mistake. Judge LinkedIn on last touch and it looks terrible, with CPMs too high and cost per conversion out of range. Turn it off, and two months later somebody internal is in your inbox asking what happened to all the Google traffic.

The channel mix, working together with the right audience and relevant creative, is going to differentiate your presence in the market. 
 

Sequence is the whole argument

None of this means channel expertise stops mattering. Connected TV still needs a real budget to do anything. Out of home is still measured on its own terms. What changed in the room was the order of operations.

Understanding the audience, meaning the psychographics and behaviors underneath the demographics, is the hard part, and it's the part most plans spend the least time on.

Distribution and activation are comparatively easy once that's done, because the data will tell you which channels and tactics to try first, and test-and-learn handles the rest. Most plans still run this backwards, starting from the channel mix and working toward a rationale.

 

At Mediate.ly this is where planning starts. If your plan still opens with a channel allocation, or you have first-party data sitting in a CRM that nobody has activated, contact us and we'd be glad to talk it through.

Join our next roundtable

If you’re interested in joining one of our upcoming roundtables, click the link for more information and we look forward to having you in our discussion! 

https://luma.com/paid-media-council-rt 

Related Articles

The Primary Care Paradox: Closing the Gap Between Mindset and Bookings
Mediate.ly Gen Z vs. Millennial: How Two Generations Decide on Primary Care Mediate.ly’s Field Signals team conducted new primary research on how Gen Z and Millennial consumers make, delay, and abandon the...
The Content Advantage is Gone
Mediate.ly The Content Advantage Is Gone. Experience Is Everything. For about a decade, content was the moat. Health systems built condition libraries, symptom checkers, physician bios, and blog archives deep...
See All News